
The main difference between a French press and a moka pot is how they brew. A French press (called a cafetière in the UK) steeps coarse coffee in hot water for about 4 minutes, then presses it through a metal mesh, making a large, full-bodied mug of coffee. A moka pot is a stovetop brewer that uses steam pressure to push hot water up through fine coffee, making a small amount of strong, espresso-like coffee in about 5 minutes. Choose a French press if you like big, smooth mugs of black coffee or brew for several people; choose a moka pot if you want strong, intense coffee for straight shots, Americanos or lattes without an espresso machine.
| French press | Moka pot | |
|---|---|---|
| How it brews | Immersion: coffee steeps in the water, then is pressed | Pressure: steam pushes water up through the coffee, about 1 to 2 bars |
| Grind | Coarse | Medium-fine, like table salt (coarser than espresso) |
| Ratio | About 1:16 (30 g coffee to 480 ml water) | About 1:10 (18 g coffee to 180 ml water in a 4-cup pot) |
| Water | 200 to 205°F, off the boil | Hot water in the base, heated on the stove |
| Brew time | About 4 minutes | About 5 minutes |
| Strength | Regular coffee strength | Strong and concentrated, served in small cups |
| Taste and body | Rich, rounded, heavy body, some sediment | Bold, intense, bittersweet, thick; no true crema |
| Serving size | Mugs; 3 to 12 cups depending on size | Small cups; 1 to 12 espresso-size cups depending on size |
| Heat source | Kettle | Stovetop; aluminum models do not work on induction |
| Best for | Black coffee, groups, medium and dark roasts | Espresso-style shots, lattes, Americanos, dark roasts |
| Cleanup | Messier: scoop out wet grounds | Easy: knock out the puck and rinse |
How a French Press Works
A French press is a glass or stainless steel carafe with a plunger and a fine metal mesh filter. All the coffee and water sit together while it steeps, and the mesh lets natural oils and some fine particles through, which gives French press coffee its heavy, rounded body. It is one of the simplest and most forgiving ways to make coffee, and it needs no paper filters.
- Heat water to 200 to 205°F, just off the boil.
- Add 30 g of coarsely ground coffee for 480 ml (16 oz) of water, about 1:16.
- Pour in the water, stir gently and put the lid on with the plunger up.
- Steep for 4 minutes.
- Press slowly and steadily, then pour it all out right away so it does not keep brewing on the grounds.
Use a coarse, even grind from a burr grinder; fine grounds slip through the mesh and make the cup muddy and bitter.
How a Moka Pot Works
A moka pot has three parts: a base for water, a funnel-shaped basket for the coffee and an upper chamber that collects the brew. As the water heats on the stove, steam builds pressure in the base and pushes the hot water up through the coffee and out into the top. The pressure is only about 1 to 2 bars, compared with about 9 bars in an espresso machine, so moka coffee is strong and syrupy but not true espresso and has little crema.
- Fill the base with hot water to just below the safety valve. Starting with hot water shortens the time on the heat and avoids a cooked, metallic taste.
- Fill the basket with medium-fine coffee and level it without tamping. For a 4-cup pot that is about 18 g.
- Screw on the top, using a towel because the base is hot, and set the pot on medium-low heat with the lid open.
- When coffee starts to flow, lower the heat. Take the pot off as soon as the stream turns pale and starts to sputter.
- Run the base under cold water to stop the brewing, stir the coffee and serve.
Our moka pot brew guide covers ratios by pot size and how to fix bitter or weak coffee.
Taste and Strength
French press coffee is full-bodied, rich and smooth, with a little sediment at the bottom of the cup. The long steep brings out chocolate, nut and fruit notes, and it works with almost any roast. Moka pot coffee is much stronger and more intense, with a thick, almost syrupy texture and a bittersweet edge. Dark and medium-dark roasts, including Italian-style espresso blends, taste best in a moka pot; very light roasts can taste sour.
Ounce for ounce, moka pot coffee is far stronger, because it uses about one part coffee to 10 parts water instead of 1 to 16. But you drink much less of it, so a small moka cup often has less caffeine than a full mug of French press. See how much caffeine is in coffee.
Health, Cleanup and Cost
- Cholesterol: neither uses a paper filter, so both let through cafestol, a coffee oil that can raise LDL cholesterol. French press coffee has more of it, and you drink it in larger amounts. If you watch your cholesterol, see filtered coffee and health.
- Cleanup: a moka pot is quick to clean: knock out the puck and rinse with hot water, without soap or the dishwasher for aluminum pots. A French press takes more work to scoop out the wet grounds and clean the mesh.
- Durability: glass French presses can break; stainless steel models and moka pots last for years. Replace the moka pot’s rubber gasket when it hardens or leaks.
- Cost: both are inexpensive, and a good basic model of either costs about as much as one or two bags of specialty coffee. Neither needs filters.
A Little History
The first press-style coffee maker was patented in France in 1852. Italians Attilio Calimani and Giulio Moneta patented a version with a sealing plunger in 1929, and Faliero Bondanini’s 1958 design became the Chambord, still made by Bodum. The moka pot was designed by Luigi De Ponti for Alfonso Bialetti in 1933 and became a fixture of Italian kitchens after World War II. Bialetti’s eight-sided Moka Express is still the classic design.
Which Should You Choose?
- Choose a French press if you drink your coffee black by the mug, brew for two or more people, want something nearly foolproof or like to try different roasts.
- Choose a moka pot if you want strong, espresso-style coffee, make milk drinks or Americanos at home, or need a compact brewer for travel and camping.
- Still not sure? Many coffee lovers keep both. Compare other brewers in moka pot vs AeroPress and French press vs drip coffee.
For milk drinks from a moka pot, see how to froth milk. For either brewer, fresh whole-bean coffee and the right setting on our grind size chart make the biggest difference.

